Is it Really Unforgettable? a yarn review

Unforgettable Yarn by Red Heart - a review

Hello Yarn Fans. I’ve been stitching with Unforgettable, a yarn made by Red Heart. Its part of my I’m-Not-a-Yarn-Snob campaign. I’m making a hat, a Victorian styled nightcap, with this and one other modern acrylic yarn. Yes, I may not be a yarn snob but I am a yarn geek and so making up a vintage item with two modern yarns in wild colors makes me feel so very clever. I’m enjoying it.

Unforgettable Yarn - a review for knitters and crocehters

Why I'm Not A Yarn Snob

Nearly every crafter who checks out my in-progress hat asks (a) how is that Unforgettable yarn and (b) when are you going to get the pattern done. The answer to (b) is …. I don’t know. Soon. Depends of how many sleepless nights I have and if I get distracted by something else (like another project). The short answer to (a) is  yes, in certain circumstances its a great yarn. The long answer? Well that’s what I have a blog for!

Some Facts About Unforgettable

  • Weight = 4. I’d call it a DK weight. Its definitely thinner than most worsted weight yarn. Its sold in balls of 3.5 oz (100g) with 269 yds (246m).
  • Material = 100% acrylic. Its shiny and very soft to the touch. I think of it as a fake silk. I always mentally categorize acrylics by the fiber they are trying to mimic. This one is a silk-mimic.
  • Construction = single ply. Its a loosely spun, single ply with some, but not much, halo on it. The thickness is pretty consistent; not too much thick’n’thin going on with this yarn.
  • Colorways = long color stripes. There are 15 colorways sold (I think). I’m working with Stained Glass (E793-3943). This is a long colorway yarn but maybe not as long as you’d expect. Each distinct color is only yard or two with gradual transitions into the next color.


How It Works Up

I was pleasantly surprised by how Unforgettable works up. Its a loose spun, single ply acrylic and I was expecting it to be splitty. Its not. I occasionally put my needle tip through the yarn and have to back out, but only rarely. And the yarn isn’t grabby so when I do make a mistake, its easy to pull a stitch free and fix it. I do want to add that I’m using metal tips and sharp points. Specifically I’m using addi Click Lace Short Tips and they are very smooth needles. I think smooth tips would be a must when working with Unforgettable. 

Here is a look at how its working up for me in my in-progress nightcap (this is pre-blocking of course). It has nice stitch definition and, being a single ply, the stitches really pop out.

knit sample with Unforgettable yarn
Knitting with Unforgettable Yarn

I did a small sample in crochet. This is just half double crochet stitches with chain spaces. I think it looks even better here than in the knitting.

a review of Unforgettable Yarn - testing in crochet
Crochet with Unforgettable Yarn

But I’m not following the recommendations provided on the ballband. Unforgettable recommends a Size 8 (5mm) knit needle and a Size J (6mm) crochet hook. That just does not work for me. In my samples here I used a Size 6 (4mm) needle and a Size G (3.75mm) hook. As I mentioned above, this yarn is thinner than most worsteds so I went down a size. Or two. Or three. A Size J hook with this stuff is just crazy-underpants-talk to me. It would not work with the way I crochet.

My Thoughts

Unforgettable has great draping qualities. Scratch that. It has fantastic draping qualities. Because of the way its made, its very soft and very smooth and it will hang beautifully in any lace you make. Being so soft and smooth and drape-y I think makes it ideal for crochet lace.

This yarn has no elasticity whatsoever. None. Zilch. Nada. Don’t use it for anything that requires negative ease because it won’t cling. Think of it as silk. There is no stretchy-clingyness to silk and there is none in this yarn either.

Unforgettable is a delicately made yarn. That’s probably why its so soft. Don’t use it in any hard-wearing garnets. Don’t use it in anything that will need to be washed a lot. It will pill. Think outerwear. Think scarfs and shawls and hats and slouchy leg warmers. No gloves. No sweaters. No socks.

Where You Can Get Some

So if I convinced you to give Unforgettable Yarn a try the good news is that its also pretty inexpensive. You can buy it online direct from Red Heart for $6.19. But I looked around and there are better deals out there.

(None of these links below are affiliates of mine. I’m not making any money off your yarn purchase so you can be sure that these really are the best deals, the best I could find anyway.)

  • Jo-Anns is currently selling all Red Heart Boutique yarns, including Unforgettable, for 25% off. I don’t know how long the sale lasts but as of right now Unforgettable is $4.87 and they have 12 colors in stock.
  • Micheals also has Unforgettable on sale and its currently $3.99. I think that price/deal is only good for on-line sales and you won’t get it if you buy from a store.
  • Walmart sells it and that’s where I bought mine. If you check online, they have multiple prices for Unforgettable. It seems to range from $4.97 to $7.78. I have no idea why. At my local store its $5.19.


Anyone else have experience with this yarn and like to share? I’d really like to hear more opinions. In fact, if there is an interest, I’d love to make independent yarn reviews a regular thing here. 

Print Friendly

Related Content


"There is no failure. Only feedback." - Robert Allen

31 Comments on "Is it Really Unforgettable? a yarn review"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
I use Unforgettable regularly. Usually for scarves. Some colorways are more fragile than others. I used the color Sunrise, and it kept breaking on me. Multiple skeins. Maybe that was just a bad batch, because I haven’t had that problem with other colors. I favor Candied, Cappuccino, and Stained Glass. And I agree with the DK weight assessment. It is NOT worsted. Lion Brand has a yarn (Landscapes) that is close to this, but I think is more closer to Worsted. It’s available in 24 colors (which is 9 more than Unforgettable’s 15). I just bought two balls to check… Read more »
Christine N

I’ve been doing yarn reviews on my blog for a few years now, and I reviewed Unforgettable last spring! It’s interesting how people can get such different experiences based on what they make worth a particular yarn.
My review for Unforgettable:
My full listing of reviews:


I love that you are using acrylics for an old-fashioned nightcap! The colors in your yarn are stunning! But you knew that…


The nightcap is stunning! I would love to see more yarn reviews whenever it tickles your fancy. I have become a fan of YarnSub (from your recommendation) and use Chibi bent tip needles now too (also at your suggestion)! I can’t wait to see the night cap finished 🙂

I recently completed a slouch hat for teenage grand daughter jn Unforgettable Tidal and same hat and simple looong scarf for my grown daughter in the Stained Glass. Both in double crochet. I too dropped down to a G hook agree it is more DK than worsted. I had a lot of variation in the thickness in both colorways. It worked nice on my hook with practically no splitting. But do not even try a Russian Join. Silk was my first thought also. This is very hard to find in Birmingham area especially the Stained Glass. Also did a scarf… Read more »